Here are the questions: a. To what other arguments is the author(s) responding? b. Is the writer disagreeing or agreeing with something? If so, what? c. What is motivating the argument? d. Are there similar ideas you’ve encountered? In the article "Big Box Stores Are Bad for Main Street"
Betsy Taylor discusses a lot of the issues regarding the economy and the "mom & pop" stores in America. Betsy's claim that Big Box stores, such as Walmart and home depot are negative for for American economy because these stores attract people away from smaller shopping areas, such as downtown. She disagrees that these places where you can buy everything in one stop is a good idea.
(Photo from Google Images)
I believe her motivation for her argument is that she has witnessed the change in America... these large stores do not truly cater to the needs of the consumer, and can take away the charm of smaller communities. It then becomes about hyper consumerism and meeting a status quo with other cities. Being born and raised in Richmond, Kentucky, I can definitely see the point that Betsy Taylor brings to the table. Downtown Richmond used to have so many small shops and stores and until recently the majority have closed down due to the fact that it can not match the competition of other stores such as Walmart or JC Penney. The mens shop Jett & Hall downtown is literally barely hanging by a thread.
Over the past four years or so Richmond has started an effort of reviving these old mom& pop style stores, but it's a giant leap of faith. Usually most places close before even making it an entire year. For example, Regal Beagle in Richmond, a newer bar/restaurant closed this past summer after barely being open a year. It's rather sad to me. Yes Walmart is a faster option, but the personal experiences or the one on one quality of these smaller shops is something that can leave an impression for a lifetime.
No comments:
Post a Comment